Advertisement

OP-ED: Beyond the ballot box: Possible lessons from China’s governance experience

The following is an op-ed by Mohamed Zahid, the former chief of Elections Commission.

___

Reflections from my 2025 study visit to China

Democracy is often discussed in terms of elections: who wins, who loses, which party forms the government and whether power can change hands peacefully. These are important measures of a competitive democratic system. But my 2025 study visit to China left me reflecting on a broader question: Is holding elections enough to make democracy work effectively for ordinary people?

China’s political system is fundamentally different from the competitive multi-party democracy practiced in countries such as the Maldives. China describes its approach as socialist democracy and, increasingly, through the practice of “whole-process people’s democracy.”

The purpose of studying China’s experience is not to argue that one political system should replace another. The more useful question is whether there is governance practices developed within China from which competitive multi-party democracies can learn.

I believe there are.

Democracy Cannot End on Election Day

One of the most interesting ideas I encountered in China was the emphasis on citizens’ participation throughout both democratic and administrative governance processes.

In competitive multi-party democracies, enormous political energy is concentrated around elections. Parties campaign, candidates make promises and citizens vote. Once the election is over, however, meaningful citizen participation can become much weaker. Many multiparty democracies have limited legislative frameworks or practical mechanisms for ongoing citizen participation.

China’s whole-process people’s democracy presents participation differently. Its official conception of the legislative framework emphasizes consultation, decision-making, implementation, supervision and feedback as interconnected elements of political participation.

This raises a legitimate question for electoral democracies:

Why should citizens participate actively only during elections every few years?

Citizens’ meaningful democratic participation and reporting could continue between elections through parliamentary consultations, local councils, public hearings, community forums, digital engagement and mechanisms through which citizens can comment on proposed legislations and policies.

My visits to grassroots institutions in China made this particularly interesting.

At the Qianmen Courtyard Council, community-level consultation demonstrated how residents could become involved in addressing practical neighborhood concerns. The legislative outreach office we visited illustrated another approach: creating channels through which grassroots views could reach legislative processes.

Competitive multiparty democracies, like Maldives, could develop their own versions of such mechanisms while preserving political pluralism, constitutional rights and electoral accountability.

Democracy Must Also Deliver

Another lesson was China’s emphasis on implementation.

Governments or political parties can produce policies, strategies and development plans. The more difficult task is turning them into results.

Citizens experience government and political parties not through policy documents but through the quality of their schools, hospitals, housing, transport, employment opportunities, public infrastructure and everyday government services.

This distinction is important in every democracy.

An election gives a government the authority to govern. It does not guarantee that the government will govern effectively.

Democratic legitimacy therefore has at least two important dimensions: The legitimacy of the process through which governments are chosen and the effectiveness with which those governments serve the people. These should not be treated as competing ideas. A successful democracy should have both.

Train People to Govern, Not Just to Win Elections

My visit to the CPC Party School and National Academy of Governance produced another important reflection.

China devotes considerable institutional attention to developing and training its officials. The system is obviously embedded within China’s particular political structure, but the underlying principle deserves wider consideration.

Political parties in competitive democracies spend enormous amounts of time and resources preparing to win elections.

But how much do they invest in preparing people to govern and deliver after winning them?

Becoming a minister, parliamentarian, councilor or senior political appointee requires knowledge of public finance, economics, administration, law, international affairs, strategic planning and the management of complex institutions.

Election victory alone provides none of these skills. The winning party should ensure that all public officials appointed are trained and experienced.

Democratic political parties could therefore invest more in policy institutes, leadership academies, candidate development and continuous political education.

Countries Need Plans Longer Than an Election Cycle

China’s approach to long-term development planning and policy consistency also deserves examination.

Competitive elections necessarily create political cycles. Governments understandably want to demonstrate achievements before the next election. The danger is that national development becomes trapped inside four- or five-year political horizons.

Infrastructure, education reform, climate adaptation, economic diversification and major institutional reforms frequently require decades, and their success depends on consistent policies rather than policies that change with every election cycle.

A mature democracy should therefore be capable of distinguishing between legitimate political competition and long-term national interests. Government and opposition do not need to agree on everything. Indeed, disagreement is essential to democracy. But there should be room for national consensus on fundamental development objectives.

In the Maldives, issues such as climate resilience, economic diversification, education, healthcare, decentralization, housing, fiscal sustainability and national infrastructure are, by their nature, longer than the lifespan of any single government.

Political parties could compete over how these objectives should be achieved without repeatedly changing whether they should be pursued.

Bring Government Closer to Communities

China’s institutional arrangements for grassroots governance also made me reconsider the relationship between national politics and everyday democracy.

National political disputes frequently dominate media coverage in electoral democracies. Yet most citizens encounter governance through very practical matters: roads, waste management, housing, utilities, schools, healthcare and local economic opportunities.

This makes local government’s ability and legislative framework for practical democratic and administrative governance extremely important. For an island nation such as Maldives, effective decentralization and stronger councils can provide an important democratic bridge between citizens and the state.

Local consultation, then, means more than occasional meetings. Councils could establish regular citizen forums, public consultations and transparent mechanisms for tracking community priorities and government responses in an effective manner.

Democracy becomes more meaningful when people can see how their participation influences decisions affecting their own communities.

Political Parties Must Become More Than Election Machines

There is another lesson worth considering.

Political parties are among the most important institutions in a multi-party democracy. Yet parties can come to focus heavily on personalities, campaigns and elections.

A mature political party can also be an institution for developing ideas and leaders.

Parties could maintain policy research units, leadership development programs, youth academies and specialist groups dealing with economics, foreign policy, social development, climate change and public administration. They are tasked to prepare people not simply to become candidates, but to become competent public officials.

This is one area where the organizational emphasis of the CPC offered a point of comparison. Again, adaptation is more useful than imitation.

Learning Without Copying

China and competitive electoral multiparty democracies have fundamentally different political structures and mechanisms of accountability.

Learning from China’s governance practices should therefore not mean abandoning the  principles of multi-party democracy. Instead, the challenge is to ask whether competitive multiparty democracies can combine their existing strengths with stronger governance capacity.

Can we retain electoral accountability while improving long-term planning?

Can we maintain vigorous opposition while encouraging cooperation where national interests demand it?

Can citizens vote freely while also participating meaningfully during the years between elections?

And can political parties become institutions that prepare people to govern rather than organizations primarily designed to win the next election?

My study visit reinforced my belief that countries should learn from governance experiences beyond their own political traditions.

China’s experience offers lessons in long-term planning, leadership development, meaningful grassroots consultation, institutional capacity and implementation. Competitive democracies offer important mechanisms of electoral accountability, political pluralism and peaceful changes of government.

The objective should not be to manufacture an artificial choice between different political systems. For the Maldives, the more relevant question is how our own democratic system can continue to evolve. Perhaps the next stage of our democratic conversation could move beyond asking simply who should govern. We could increasingly ask how we want to be governed. A democracy should allow citizens to choose their leaders. But its success must ultimately also be reflected in the strength of its institutions, the quality of public participation, the competence of its leadership and its ability to serve the people.

The most valuable lessons I brought home from China is that democracy should not stop at the ballot box. It should continue every day through participation, accountable institutions and governance that delivers.

___

Note: Mohamed Zahid is former President of the Maldives Elections Commission. He spent nearly a decade at UNDP, contributing to the drafting of Maldives’ decentralization legislation and establishing local governance frameworks. His previous senior roles include Vice President of the Human Rights Commission of the Maldives, Vice President of the Local Government Authority and Deputy Minister of Law and Gender. This article is based on observations and discussions during a study visit to China in 2025. Its purpose is to examine governance practices that may offer useful lessons for the Maldives while recognizing the fundamental differences between the two countries' political systems.

Advertisement
Comment